1Objectives, ethics and quality (ISA 200, IESBA Code, ISQM 1, ISA 220)
An audit gives reasonable, not absolute, assurance. The auditor uses professional judgement and scepticism. The IESBA Code has five principles: integrity, objectivity, professional competence and due care, confidentiality and professional behaviour. It names five threats: self-interest, self-review, advocacy, familiarity and intimidation. Firms manage quality under ISQM 1; the engagement partner under ISA 220.
Go deeper
Reasonable assurance is high but not absolute.
Five principles: integrity, objectivity, competence and due care, confidentiality, professional behaviour.
Five threats: self-interest, self-review, advocacy, familiarity, intimidation.
Worked exampleThe firm kept a client's books and now audits them. That is a self-review threat: use a separate team, or decline one of the two services.
DiagramThe audit risk model
Inherent riskbefore any controls
×
Control riskthe client's controls fail
×
Detection riskthe auditor's procedures miss it
=
Audit riska wrong opinion
2Accepting the engagement (ISA 210)
Before accepting, confirm the preconditions: the financial reporting framework is acceptable, and management accepts its responsibility for the financial statements, for internal control and for giving access. The terms are agreed in an engagement letter.
Go deeper
Preconditions: an acceptable reporting framework, and management accepting its responsibilities.
The engagement letter sets out scope, responsibilities and the form of the report.
If management limits the scope so that a disclaimer would follow, do not accept.
Worked exampleA new client refuses to let the auditor contact its previous auditor. Without a good reason, the firm should decline the engagement.
3Planning, risk and materiality (ISA 300, 315, 320, 240)
ISA 315 (Revised 2019) asks for an understanding of the entity, its environment, its controls and its IT, and an assessment of inherent and control risk at assertion level. Materiality is set for the statements as a whole; performance materiality is lower. Fraud: revenue recognition is a presumed risk that can be rebutted. Management override cannot be rebutted, so journal entries are always tested.
Go deeper
Performance materiality is lower than overall materiality, to leave room for undetected misstatements.
Two presumed fraud risks: revenue recognition (can be rebutted) and management override (never rebutted).
Significant risks always get substantive procedures aimed at them.
Worked exampleProfit before tax is AED 4 million and the firm uses 5%: overall materiality 200,000. At 75%, performance materiality is 150,000.
DiagramThe audit from start to finish
1AcceptEthics, competence, preconditions, engagement letter
2PlanStrategy, materiality, understanding the entity
3Assess risksRisks of material misstatement, significant risks, fraud
4RespondTests of controls and substantive procedures
4Responses and evidence (ISA 330, 500, 505, 520, 530, 540)
Respond with tests of controls and substantive procedures. Evidence must be sufficient and appropriate. External evidence is more reliable than internal, written more than oral, original more than copies. Confirmations, analytical procedures, sampling and auditing estimates each have their own standard.
Go deeper
Evidence must be sufficient (how much) and appropriate (relevance and reliability).
No reply to a confirmation means alternative procedures, not acceptance.
Material inventory means attending the count, unless that is impracticable.
Worked exampleErrors of 10,000 in a sample of 500,000, from a population of 4,000,000: the projected misstatement is 2% × 4,000,000 = 80,000.
DiagramHow reliable is the evidence? Strongest first
1Evidence the auditor obtains directly, such as reperformance or attending a count
2Written evidence sent straight to the auditor by an outside party
3Outside documents that passed through the client's hands
4Internal documents produced under strong controls
5Spoken answers from management
5Using the work of others (ISA 402, 600, 610, 620)
The auditor can use the work of internal audit, an expert or a service organisation's auditor only after evaluating it. The auditor keeps sole responsibility for the opinion. Group audits follow ISA 600 (Revised), with the group engagement team directing component work.
Go deeper
The auditor alone is responsible for the opinion, whoever else helps.
Internal audit: evaluate objectivity, competence and a systematic approach.
A Type 2 report on a service organisation also covers how controls operated over a period.
Worked exampleA valuer's report supports a property value. The auditor checks the valuer's competence and assumptions, and the audit report does not mention the valuer.
6Completion (ISA 450, 560, 570, 580, 260, 265)
Accumulate the misstatements found and ask for them to be corrected. Look for events up to the date of the report. Going concern: if management's assessment covers less than twelve months from the date of the financial statements, ask them to extend it. Obtain written representations. Report significant control deficiencies in writing to those charged with governance.
Go deeper
Subsequent events: active procedures up to the date of the auditor's report.
Going concern: management's assessment covers at least 12 months from the reporting date.
Written representations support other evidence. Refusal normally leads to a disclaimer.
Worked exampleA customer owing a material amount at the year end goes bankrupt before the report is signed. It is an adjusting event: the receivable is written down.
7The auditor's report (ISA 700, 701, 705, 706)
Unmodified opinion when the statements are fairly presented. Qualified ('except for') when a matter is material but not pervasive. Adverse when a misstatement is material and pervasive. Disclaimer when the auditor cannot get enough evidence and the possible effect is material and pervasive. Key audit matters are required for listed entities. Emphasis of matter does not change the opinion.
Go deeper
The Opinion section comes first, then the Basis for Opinion.
Key audit matters are required for listed entities and never replace a modified opinion.
An Emphasis of Matter points to something already disclosed properly.
Worked exampleThe auditor cannot get evidence about one material balance, and the effect is not pervasive: qualified opinion ('except for').
DiagramWhich modified opinion?
The problem
Material but not pervasive
Material and pervasive
The statements are misstated
Qualified opinion
Adverse opinion
Not enough evidence could be obtained
Qualified opinion
Disclaimer of opinion
8Documentation and the UAE rules (ISA 230)
Working papers must let an experienced auditor understand what was done, the evidence and the conclusions. The file is assembled soon after the report and kept for at least five years. In the UAE, only auditors licensed and registered with the Ministry of Economy may sign audit reports.
Go deeper
Working papers must let an experienced auditor understand the work, the evidence and the conclusions.
The file is assembled soon after the report, normally within 60 days, and then kept.
In the UAE only auditors registered with the Ministry of Economy sign audit reports.
Worked exampleA team member wants to add a missing working paper three months after the report. It may be added only with a note of who added it, when and why.
This guide is general study material. It is not legal or tax advice, and it does not replace the ACCA course. Laws and standards change: always check the current text.